top of page

Evaluating Diagnostic Accuracy and Cost Implications in MASLD Fibrosis Staging

As noninvasive tests (NITs) continue to replace liver biopsy in MASLD clinical practice and trials, the performance characteristics of different modalities remain under active evaluation. A recent analysis compared Magnetic Resonance Elastography (MRE) and Vibration-Controlled Transient Elastography (VCTE) in identifying F2–F3 fibrosis—patients who may be eligible for pharmacologic intervention.


Study Overview: MRE vs VCTE

In a cohort of 103 MASLD patients:

  • MRE identified 18 patients with F2–F3 fibrosis.

  • VCTE identified 33 patients as F2–F3.

While VCTE identified more patients as treatment-eligible, further inspection revealed that 15 of the 33 VCTE-classified F2–F3 cases were not supported by MRE or by expected disease prevalence.


This suggests a false-positive rate of approximately 45% for VCTE in this cohort—consistent with prior literature showing VCTE’s tendency to overstage fibrosis, particularly in patients with elevated BMI or hepatic inflammation.


Projecting to Larger Populations

Assuming these findings generalize, what would this look like in a screening cohort of 1,000 patients?


MRE

VCTE

Patients flagged F2–F3

175

320

Estimated true positives

175

175

Estimated false positives

~0

~145

Annual treatment cost at $47,400

$8.3M

$15.2M

The difference in total cost—$6.9 million annually—is attributable to false-positive patients receiving treatment under the VCTE pathway.


Technical Considerations

  • VCTE is known to have technical failure rates as high as 15–20% in patients with obesity.

  • Many trials and clinics require 2–3 VCTE scans per patient to ensure an interpretable result.

  • MRE, by contrast, has a technical success rate >98%, and evaluates the liver in its entirety.

Importantly, MRE’s repeatability coefficient (~10%) allows for greater confidence in monitoring change over time, compared to repeatability coefficients of 50–70% reported for VCTE in some populations.


Implications for Clinical Trials and Payer Strategy

  • From a clinical trial perspective, over-inclusion due to VCTE overstaging may dilute treatment effects and increase sample size requirements.

  • From a payer standpoint, initiating expensive therapies in false-positive patients has direct cost implications, particularly when NITs are used as gatekeeping tools for drug eligibility.


Conclusion

As noninvasive fibrosis staging tools are increasingly relied upon in MASLD, test specificity and reproducibility become critical—not only for individual patient care, but for trial design, payer policy, and system-level efficiency.

More studies will be needed to validate optimal cutoff strategies across populations, but these findings highlight the importance of understanding not just who gets flagged—but whether those patients actually have the disease in question.

 
 
 

13 Comments


Your focus on MASLD fibrosis staging reflects a commitment to advancing patient care through precise, cost-effective, and innovative diagnostics. Just as accurate staging guides better treatment, selecting the right cricket bat ensures peak performance, making Willcraft bats a winning choice. For cricket enthusiasts seeking top-notch equipment, the choice to buy Willcraft Kashmir willow cricket bat or buy Willcraft plain custom leather cricket bat offers unparalleled quality and performance. Whether you’re a beginner or a seasoned player, selecting the right cricket bat can significantly impact your game, and Willcraft’s craftsmanship ensures durability and precision.


When you buy Willcraft Kashmir willow cricket bat, you are opting for a bat crafted from one of the finest types of willow available. Kashmir willow is…


Like

Appreciating the pursuit of precision, your focus on MASLD diagnostics inspires innovation in balancing accuracy, patient comfort, and healthcare costs effectively. Just as civil lawyers navigate complex disputes with expertise, MASLD diagnostic strategies demand precision, cost-efficiency, and clear pathways toward optimal resolutions for patients. When dealing with legal disputes that do not involve criminal charges, a civil lawyer plays a crucial role in helping clients navigate civil court cases. Whether the issue is related to property, contracts, family matters, or personal injury, a skilled civil lawyer guides individuals through the complex legal process to achieve a fair resolution.


A civil lawyer specializes in non-criminal legal matters, representing clients in disputes that typically involve private rights and obligations. These disputes are…


Like

Interesting to see how technical performance differences between MRE and VCTE can influence both patient eligibility and overall treatment costs. If you're as curious as I am about solutions blogs, I strongly suggest taking a look at my latest post. In today’s fast-paced world, spiritual tools play a significant role in attracting positivity, wealth, wisdom, and protection. At Festmarket, you can easily find the most authentic and powerful yantras for your needs. You can explore and purchase the sri astalaxmi yantra online for prosperity, the sri mahakali yantra online for protection, and the sri saraswati yantra online for wisdom, all from the comfort of your home.

These divine yantras are not just decorative items but powerful spiritual symbols designed to channel divine energy into…

Edited
Like

The analysis makes it clear how false positives can not only affect trial outcomes but also place unnecessary financial strain on healthcare systems. If you're as curious as I am about solutions blogs, I strongly suggest taking a look at my latest post. When businesses or construction companies look for cost-effective and high-quality modular solutions, two things often come to mind — porta cabin price and puf panels. These are essential components for setting up temporary or permanent structures with speed, durability, and efficiency. Technopuff Solutions is a trusted name in the industry, known for delivering premium quality products at competitive rates while ensuring customer satisfaction.

Introduction to Porta Cabins and PUF Panels

In today’s fast-paced construction world, speed and quality are equally…

Like

Very insightful comparison between MRE and VCTE. The cost implications really highlight why specificity matters so much in MASLD management. If you're as curious as I am about solutions blogs, I strongly suggest taking a look at my latest post. In today’s competitive market, every organization faces the challenge of improving operations while achieving steady growth. This is where the expertise of a business development consultant and the efficiency brought by business process management services can become game-changers. Sugoya India, a leader in innovative business solutions, specializes in bridging the gap between strategy and execution, ensuring that businesses not only survive but thrive in an evolving environment.

Understanding the Role of a Business Development Consultant

A business development consultant is more than just…

Like
Recent Posts
bottom of page